File(s) under permanent embargo
Encyclopaedia, genealogy and tradition in pursuit of pluralist jurisprudence
journal contribution
posted on 2023-05-20, 06:04 authored by Allen, JGThis article explores the different avenues for pursuing pluralist jurisprudence. Using the critique of Neil MacCormick’s ‘institutional’ pluralism (i.e. that it lapses into methodological monism) as a departure point, I explore the presuppositions and pre-commitments of genealogical and empirico-positivist approaches to legal studies. By reference to Alasdair MacIntyre’s Gifford Lectures on encyclopaedia, genealogy, and tradition, I defend an empiricopositivist view of law and legal order, in which legal systems and their constituent entities exist as ‘institutional facts’. Following MacIntyre, genealogy is ultimately unable to subject itself to its own methods and must devolve into a post-truth contest for power. However, a genealogical approach can enrich scholarship, revealing the inherent limits of theory and tempering the excesses of encyclopedic canonism. I suggest MacIntyre’s preferred approach, tradition in the sense of a craft guild, as a third way worthy of consideration.
History
Publication title
Transnational Legal TheoryVolume
8Issue
4Pagination
399-406ISSN
2041-4005Department/School
Faculty of LawPublisher
RoutledgePlace of publication
United KingdomRights statement
Copyright 2017 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis GroupRepository Status
- Restricted