Morris, IS and Frandsen, M and Ferguson, SG, Compliance with ecological momentary assessment protocols and its effects on study data, Society for Research on Nicotine and Tobacco 21st Annual Meeting, 25 - 28 February, 2015, Philadelphia Pennsylvania, pp. 234. (2015) [Conference Extract]
Objective: It is commonly noted that non-compliance with ecological momentary assessment (EMA) protocols has the potential to systematically bias study data. The purpose of this study was to document the relationship between three measures of protocol compliance - namely, responding to random prompts, logging events, and daily monitoring duration -, and to explore their impact on self-reported affect, arousal and craving.
Methods: Data were taken from a multi-site study interested in the social determinants of smoking. Participants (n=73) used study-issued smartphones to monitor their smoking and activities in real time for up to four weeks (M=27.2 days per participant).
Results: On average participants responded to 77% of random prompts per day, however on a third of all monitoring days fewer than 75% of random prompts were completed; this accounted for less than two thirds of days during which any non-compliant behaviour was observed. Compliance with study protocols did not predict mean daily levels of affect, arousal or craving, but did predict both range and maximum values of these variables.
Conclusions: The assessment of random prompt compliance may not be an adequate proxy measure of other forms of non-compliant behaviour. Researchers should take care to monitor participant compliance with study protocols as poor compliance may impact on data quality.
FUNDING: This work was supported by an internal grant from the University of Tasmania awarded to Dr Ferguson.
JUSTIFICATION: It is important to understand how compliance with study protocols can impact on study data.
|Item Type:||Conference Extract|
|Research Division:||Psychology and Cognitive Sciences|
|Research Field:||Health, Clinical and Counselling Psychology|
|Objective Group:||Public Health (excl. Specific Population Health)|
|Objective Field:||Substance Abuse|
|Author:||Morris, IS (Miss Isabelle Morris)|
|Author:||Frandsen, M (Dr Mai Frandsen)|
|Author:||Ferguson, SG (Associate Professor Stuart Ferguson)|
|Funding Support:||National Health and Medical Research Council (1002874)|
|Downloads:||5 View Download Statistics|
Repository Staff Only: item control page