eCite Digital Repository

Charms, challenges and hidden gems, reflecting on the use of QCA for a health care PhD


Carnes, DM, Charms, challenges and hidden gems, reflecting on the use of QCA for a health care PhD, Proceedings of the First International Conference on Public Policy, 26-28 June 2013, Grenoble, France (2013) [Non Refereed Conference Paper]

PDF (Manuscript of paper)
Not available

PDF (Abstract for paper)
Not available


The use of Configurational Comparative Methods (CCM) offers opportunities to health care research. This paper will focus on the use of fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) for a PhD thesis in a health discipline area. It will outline the ‘charms’ of the methodology, discuss some of the ‘challenges’ that were dealt with and reveal some ‘hidden gems’ as well. By applying a qualitative descriptor to data, fsQCA allows for a rich interpretation of cases. In obtaining data for this thesis, a survey was distributed to nurses employed in rural clinical settings. The survey collected information about each nurse’s attitude to safety climate and their views of reporting and disclosure of a hypothetical medication error, along with some demographic information pertinent to the analysis. Whilst statistical analysis was undertaken, it is through the analysis conducted using fsQCA that the complexity between attitude to safety climate and views of error reporting and disclosure becomes apparent. Such is the charm of fsQCA (and other forms of CCM). In undertaking the thesis challenges arose. One of the hidden gems of fsQCA is it may be used effectively to undertake research involving areas of ethical sensitivity, but its use in these situations may come at the expense of modifications in research design that do not strictly adhere to methodological conventions of QCA. However, without these modifications it is likely that the data obtained may have been limited. What has resulted is a contribution to research that has the potential to inform theory and assist in policy development in relation to how rural clinical worksites deal with error reporting and disclosure.

Item Details

Item Type:Non Refereed Conference Paper
Keywords:Configurational Methods, health care, reflection
Research Division:Human Society
Research Group:Policy and administration
Research Field:Public policy
Objective Division:Health
Objective Group:Evaluation of health and support services
Objective Field:Health policy evaluation
UTAS Author:Carnes, DM (Dr Deb Carnes)
ID Code:90405
Year Published:2013
Deposited By:Health Sciences B
Deposited On:2014-04-03
Last Modified:2015-10-01

Repository Staff Only: item control page