eCite Digital Repository

Is there a Sovietology of South-East Asian studies?


Jones, DM and Smith, MLR, Is there a Sovietology of South-East Asian studies?, International Affairs, 77, (4) pp. 843-865 . ISSN 0020-5850 (2001) [Refereed Article]

DOI: doi:10.1111/1468-2346.00222


This article provides an indictment of the study of South-East Asian international relations by confronting head-on the problems that have arisen within t his field, in particular the way in which Western academics ended up colluding with deeply illiberal regimes in the area, which excluded dissenting opinions, often by deliberately denouncing these opinions as 'polemical'. This study uses the discipline of Sovietology to explore the reasons why South-East Asian studies developed into a closed community of scholarship, often hostile to dissenting viewpoints. The disciplines bear comparison because they both manifestly failed to predict the cataclysms that befell their respective areas of study. The analysis identifies similarities in the way in which the two disciplines seemed to ignore sceptical voices and evolved a shared belief in 'system stability'. As a result, both Soviet studies and the study of South-East Asian international relations developed serious methodological flaws. However, this study argues that South-East Asian studies suffered even more severe disciplinary shortcomings than its Sovieto-logical counterpart because the academic space was further de-intellectualized by the pervasive influence of the authoritarian South-East Asian developmental state which blurred the distinction between scholarship and bureaucracy and which succeeded in co-opting Western academics. The result was to create a field of study that promulgated the tyranny of the single truth, which erroneously perceived South-East Asia as a region of domestic tranquillity and regional order. What, in fact, emerged was an intellectual culture of self-censorship that kept South-East Asian studies within tacit, self-regulated boundaries.

Item Details

Item Type:Refereed Article
Research Division:Human Society
Research Group:Political science
Research Field:International relations
Objective Division:Law, Politics and Community Services
Objective Group:International relations
Objective Field:International relations not elsewhere classified
UTAS Author:Jones, DM (Dr David Jones)
ID Code:21400
Year Published:2001
Web of Science® Times Cited:5
Deposited By:Government
Deposited On:2001-08-01
Last Modified:2011-10-10

Repository Staff Only: item control page