File(s) under permanent embargo
Difficult literature on Goodreads: reading Alexis Wright's The Swan Book
journal contribution
posted on 2023-05-21, 07:36 authored by Emmett StinsonEmmett Stinson, Driscoll, BThis article considers Alexis Wright's novel The Swan Book (2013) and argues that the text's difficulty, which recalls literary modernism, should be understood as a Latourian affordance. An affordance is a quality that facilitates interaction between objective and subjective elements within readerly networks. To analyze this affordance, we examine two influential accounts of literary difficulty: George Steiner's (1978) conceptual schema of four kinds of difficulty (contingent, modal, tactical and ontological) and Leonard Diepeveen's (2003) historicised account of modernist difficulty and the various rhetorical claims made about its value. We counterpoise these accounts with an analysis of 99 Goodreads reviews of The Swan Book. We find that many Goodreads reviews foreground affective and social qualities, in which difficulty becomes a shared problem for readers. They thereby resist the traditional imperative to aesthetic judgment and offer a new set of aesthetic responses to difficulty, which we term post-critical reviews.
History
Publication title
Textual Practice: An International Journal of Radical Literary StudiesVolume
36Pagination
94 -115ISSN
0950-236XDepartment/School
School of HumanitiesPublisher
Routledge Taylor & Francis LtdPlace of publication
4 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, England, Oxfordshire, Ox14 4RnRights statement
© 2020 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis GroupRepository Status
- Restricted