eCite Digital Repository

'The prisoners could not have that fair and impartial trial which justice demands': a fair criminal trial in 19th century Australia

Citation

Plater, D and Geason, V, 'The prisoners could not have that fair and impartial trial which justice demands': a fair criminal trial in 19th century Australia, Canterbury Law Review, 25 pp. 161-203. ISSN 0112-0581 (2019) [Refereed Article]

Copyright Statement

Copyright 2019 Canterbury Law Review

Official URL: https://www.canterbury.ac.nz/law/research/clr/

Abstract

The notion of a "fair and impartial trial which justice demands" requires jurors to have regard only to the evidence presented at trial and discount anything they may hear or read outside court. Prejudicial publicity and prejudgement challenging an impartial jury is not a new problem, but have proved problematic since at least the 1800s. This article considers how trial by media was a recurring 19th-century concern in both sensational and routine criminal cases in England and Australia. The authors draw on the extensive press archives of the period and through examples of 19th-century Australian case studies (reinforced by English examples) examine the problem of prejudicial pre-trial publicity and the various 19th-century remedies to address publicity and bias. It is argued that these remedies were of little utility and trust was placed in the ability of 19th-century jurors to heed judicial directions to have regard to only the evidence led at trial. Though this premise was (and remains) questioned, 19th-century juries proved capable of ignoring even the most hostile pre-trial publicity and an impartial jury was not an ignorant jury. It is argued that 19th-century jurors ultimately had to be trusted to follow judicial directions. This premise remains but its continued validity is now further challenged by the internet and social media.

Item Details

Item Type:Refereed Article
Keywords:prisoners - conduct of life, justice - social aspects, jury, nineteenth century, judicial opinions, trial practice
Research Division:Law and Legal Studies
Research Group:Law in context
Research Field:Criminal law
Objective Division:Law, Politics and Community Services
Objective Group:Justice and the law
Objective Field:Criminal justice
UTAS Author:Plater, D (Dr David Plater)
ID Code:138484
Year Published:2019
Deposited By:Office of the Faculty of Law
Deposited On:2020-04-09
Last Modified:2020-07-27
Downloads:0

Repository Staff Only: item control page