eCite Digital Repository

Communicating forensic scientific expertise: an analysis of expert reports and corresponding testimony in Tasmanian courts

Citation

Reid, CA and Howes, LM, Communicating forensic scientific expertise: an analysis of expert reports and corresponding testimony in Tasmanian courts, Science and Justice, 60, (2) pp. 108-119. ISSN 1355-0306 (2020) [Refereed Article]


Preview
PDF (Pre-print)
Pending copyright assessment - Request a copy
619Kb
  

Official URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/...

DOI: doi:10.1016/j.scijus.2019.09.007

Abstract

Forensic criminology examines the use of forensic science in society. Justice can be hampered, for example, if the communication of forensic scientific findings is unclear or misleading, even if unintentionally. Although various recommendations guide the communication of forensic science, it is unclear whether they are reflected in practice. This study explored the communication of forensic biology in 10 cases of major crimes against the person heard in the Tasmanian Supreme Court, where the standard practice is to issue brief summary reports in the first instance. The content of expert reports and corresponding testimony was analysed to determine its adherence to recommendations outlined in standards, practice notes, and research. While reports were found to be very brief, testimony elaborated on all major elements. Mostly elicited by the prosecution, some elements were volunteered by expert witnesses, or raised by defence. Overall, expert evidence in courts—but not reports (due to the use of brief summary reports)—largely adhered to recommendations. Further research is needed to determine the prevalence and effectiveness of alternative approaches to communication that were identified in certain cases.

Item Details

Item Type:Refereed Article
Keywords:forensic science, forensic studies, expert reports, expert testimony
Research Division:Studies in Human Society
Research Group:Criminology
Research Field:Courts and Sentencing
Objective Division:Law, Politics and Community Services
Objective Group:Justice and the Law
Objective Field:Criminal Justice
UTAS Author:Reid, CA (Miss Carmen Reid)
UTAS Author:Howes, LM (Dr Loene Howes)
ID Code:136394
Year Published:2020
Deposited By:Office of the School of Social Sciences
Deposited On:2019-12-18
Last Modified:2020-03-27
Downloads:0

Repository Staff Only: item control page