Adams, VM and Pressey, RL and Naidoo, R, Opportunity costs: who really pays for conservation?, Biological Conservation, 143 pp. 439-448. ISSN 0006-3207 (2010) [Refereed Article]
Copyright 2009 Elsevier Ltd.
Designing conservation areas entails costs that, if considered explicitly, can be minimized while still achieving conservation targets. Here we focus on opportunity costs which measure forgone benefits from alternative land uses. Conservation planning studies often use partial estimates of costs, but the extent to which these result in actual efficiencies has not been demonstrated. Our study partitions land costs into three distinct opportunity costs to smallholder agriculture, soybean agriculture and ranching. We demonstrate that opportunity costs to single stakeholder groups can be inaccurate measures of true opportunity costs and can inadvertently shift conservation costs to affect groups of stakeholders disproportionately. Additionally, we examine how spatial correlations between costs as well as target size affect the performance of opportunity costs to single stakeholder groups as surrogate measures of true opportunity costs. We conclude that planning with opportunity costs to single stakeholder groups can result in cost burdens to other groups that could undermine the long-term success of conservation. Thus, an understanding of the spatial distributions of opportunity costs that are disaggregated to groups of stakeholders is necessary to make informed decisions about priority conservation areas.
|Item Type:||Refereed Article|
|Keywords:||opportunity costs, conservation planning, reserve-selection, trade-offs, agricultural conversion, developing country|
|Research Division:||Environmental Sciences|
|Research Group:||Environmental Science and Management|
|Research Field:||Environmental Management|
|Objective Group:||Ecosystem Assessment and Management|
|Objective Field:||Ecosystem Assessment and Management at Regional or Larger Scales|
|UTAS Author:||Adams, VM (Dr Vanessa Adams)|
|Web of Science® Times Cited:||90|
|Deposited By:||Geography and Spatial Science|
Repository Staff Only: item control page