eCite Digital Repository

'The whip is a very contagious kind of thing': flogging and humanitarian reform in penal Australia

Citation

Edmonds, P and Maxwell-Stewart, H, 'The whip is a very contagious kind of thing': flogging and humanitarian reform in penal Australia, Journal of Colonialism & Colonial History, 17, (1) Article 613283. ISSN 1532-5768 (2016) [Refereed Article]

Copyright Statement

Copyright © 2016 The Johns Hopkins University Press. This article first appeared in Journal of Colonialism & Colonial History, Volume 17, Issue 1, Spring, 2016, pages 1-16.

DOI: doi:10.1353/cch.2016.0006

Abstract

This paper traces humanitarian debates over corporal punishment and the use of the lash in the Australian colonies in the nineteenth century, with particular attention to Quakers James Backhouse and George Washington Walkerís interventions in penal discipline in colonial Van Diemenís Land. It examine the ways that corporal punishment of convicts and Aboriginal peoples was framed through abolitionist eyes and explores in detail specific objections to the lash, including ideas around suffering, abstract vengeance and pain. The paper considers the move to other punishment strategies such as silent and solitary confinement, promoted in place of the lash. As we show, the evidence provided by the travelling investigative Quakers did much to inform the 1837 Select Committee on Transportation chaired by William Molesworth. The same report is also credited with reducing the rate of flogging in the penal colonies. However, while the Molesworth Committee is regarded as a decisive turning point in the history of Britainís deployment of convict labour, we argue that a shift in punishment strategies was already well underway before the late 1830s. Using new data on punishments awarded, we demonstrate that in Van Diemenís Land the demise of the lash had begun well before the Molesworth Committee met. We conclude by arguing that the association between the great humanitarian moment and the demise of flagellation so often associated Molesworth, was more complex and less direct than is often supposed.

Item Details

Item Type:Refereed Article
Keywords:Convict Transportation, History Australia, Humanitarianism, History of punishment
Research Division:History and Archaeology
Research Group:Historical Studies
Research Field:Australian History (excl. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander History)
Objective Division:Expanding Knowledge
Objective Group:Expanding Knowledge
Objective Field:Expanding Knowledge through Studies of Human Society
Author:Edmonds, P (Associate Professor Penny Edmonds)
Author:Maxwell-Stewart, H (Professor Hamish Maxwell-Stewart)
ID Code:108559
Year Published:2016
Funding Support:Australian Research Council (LP140100623)
Deposited By:Humanities
Deposited On:2016-04-22
Last Modified:2018-03-08
Downloads:53 View Download Statistics

Repository Staff Only: item control page