eCite Digital Repository

Some of the lawyers don’t ask the questions I think they’re really meaning to: Experiences of communication about forensic science in criminal cases

Citation

Howes, LM, Some of the lawyers don't ask the questions I think they're really meaning to: Experiences of communication about forensic science in criminal cases, ANZAPPL (ACT) / RANZCP Faculty of Forensic Psychiatry Conference, 25-28 November, 2015, Canberra (2015) [Conference Extract]

Microsoft Word (Conference Abstract - Poster presentation)
Pending copyright assessment - Request a copy
22Kb
  

Abstract

This poster presents the findings of interviews with legal practitioners and forensic scientists about the communication of forensic scientific evidence in the criminal justice system. Legal practitioners (including Supreme Court judges, Crown prosecutors, and criminal defence lawyers; n = 12), and case-reporting forensic biologists and chemists (n = 27) from Australian jurisdictions were invited to participate in the research. Participants engaged in semi-structured interviews about how well their communication about forensic evidence met their information needs, given their roles in the criminal justice system. The use of technical language and limited case-specific detail made reliance on expert reports a challenge for legal practitioners. Participants from all groups reported that communication at pre-trial conferences facilitated both leading and presenting expert evidence effectively during a trial. However, while participants concurred that making forensic science comprehensible to the judge and jury was a shared responsibility, forensic scientists’ opportunities to explain clearly in court were impacted by the questions asked of them by lawyers. Implications for practice are discussed in terms of ensuring that forensic science is understood well, presented clearly, and used effectively in criminal trials.

Item Details

Item Type:Conference Extract
Keywords:expert evidence, legal practitioners, forensic scientists, communication
Research Division:Law and Legal Studies
Research Group:Law
Research Field:Criminal Law and Procedure
Objective Division:Law, Politics and Community Services
Objective Group:Justice and the Law
Objective Field:Criminal Justice
Author:Howes, LM (Dr Loene Howes)
ID Code:105210
Year Published:2015
Deposited By:Social Sciences
Deposited On:2015-12-14
Last Modified:2015-12-21
Downloads:0

Repository Staff Only: item control page